seen it last night. im not so sure about the heaps of praise its getting. dont get me wrong im not gonna slate it, i was tired and had two seven yr olds nipping my head but to me it just didnt live up to the hype. the effects are beutifull and seamless but i feel sometimes they take over these films the plot was good but some of the writing was a little shoddy eg: yoda has always been this wise old master but some of the lines he spoke were imo out of charachter, while i cant really pin it down, and i am paraphrasing here, he was coming out with something like "kick your butt will I" (not a direct quote but it was similar.
nat portman and hayden C were a little wooden especially in the last scene between her and hayden whe they had the big argument.
i dont think that the character of aniken would have turned so easy and did what he did, i feel that the plot let itself down here and could have been expanded.
it WAS an enjoyable film it IS vissually stunning and it DOES tie up the loose ends between 1 & 4
make your own minds up.
ps im going back to see it probly wed night with my wife so maybe get to enjoy it a little better.