Topic:Report Post to Moderators
I dont believe that there are 2 systems of scoring in Thailand. I do think that there are lots of different translations of the rules into English that conflict. But i think it is the translations that conflict rather than the rules.
My understanding of this comes from sitting with thais watching tapes and debating the descisions. My understanding of the rules today is completely different to what I understood 15 years ago. There has never been a time when I have been told.."Ah...but that was Stadium rules"
I believe that the the Stadium fights are so evenly matched that the first 2 rounds are often scored even purely because they are even. This is due to the fact that they are 2 fighters at the top of their game who are equally skilled, and are working out the opponents weaknesses before committing to attacks that may score against them.
If the promoters think one fighter is slightly stronger than the other or has an advantage they even make the stronger fighter make weight 1 or 2 pounds less in weight difference to ensure the fight is even.
The so called 'Sport Muay Thai' or Non Stadium fights are obviously at a lower level and therefore has fighters of different ability competing. It may be a top Thai against a westerner that doesnt have the experience that the Thai does and therefore the judges are able to make a distinct descision in the first two rounds and score them accordingly. Weight is never usually a major issue in these fights.
Eventually when the dominant fighters from these shows rise to the top of the pile they may someday fight at the stadiums and will probably draw the first 2 rounds against an equally schooled fighter.
It may even be a tournament with 2 Thais fighting but over 3 rounds for more money than they have ever seen, which may in itself could invoke recklessness and a change in strategy. The same fighter may choose to fight a different fight if it were 5 rounds.