Hi Dave, I didn't actually say you were wrong mate. I did say my impression as a referee was that I thought Andy won but I would reserve judgment until I see the video as it can be difficult to judge and referee. As you correctly point out, the issue is the comparative effect of the French fighter's low kicks, the effect of Andy's body kicks and Andy's knees to the back etc. I think Paul gave the fight to the French lad by one point, and Dean the fight to Andy by one point. I know speaking to Dean that he also felt, like you, the knock down round was a 10:8 round but gave round two to Andy and not a drawn round. I certainly don't want to make an issue out of one decision on a show that was well judged, but I think the issue of low kick effect versus body kicks is an important issue to explore and if I do end up disagreeing with you mate I will refer the issue to Thai judges for their opinion.