NOTICE:
The version of Internet Explorer that you are using is outdated and not officially supported by this site. We heavily suggest upgrading to a more modern browser using one of these links: Firefox, IE, Opera, Safari or Google Chrome. If you have any questions regarding this, please contact us.
NOTICE:
Currently, you have Javascript disabled. Many of the features on this site require Javascript in order to function. It is highly recommended for you to enable Javascript in order to use this site to its fullest. For more info, please contact us.
The Ax Forum
Muay Thai & Kickboxing Forum Mixed Martial Arts Forum Boxing Forum Fight Training Forum Off Topic Forum
Help Center Forum Rules New Account Registration
Topic:Report Post to Moderators

The purpose of this form is to allow users to assist the moderation in maintaining the forum by reporting posts that are breaking the rules. You should only report posts that appear to be breaking one of the forum rules. This feature should NOT be abused. If we feel someone is abusing this feature, we will moderate their account accordingly.

The identity of users who report posts are not divulged during the moderation process.

The post that you are reporting is shown below the form. If this is not the post you intended to report, then click back and report the appropriate post.

Your Ax Name:
Your Password:

What rule is this post breaking?



TonyMyers
Posted: 2012-06-22 04:45:51
James, I can't direct you to anywhere in particular that says that, other than articles I have written personally, which you perhaps will not consider to be that useful in this particular debate - although some have been published in Thailand. Actually, I would also assume the majority of Thai judges will say all techniques can score the same. However, what is done in practice is that particular targets and techniques are favoured. The application of unwritten rules in sport is not just limited to Muay Thai, a number of sports have a set of written rules of 'unwritten rules' or normative rules.

I interviewed a number of top Thai judges, experienced Thai trainers and top Thai boxers in Thailand over a period of years as part of a PhD study. They were very consistent in their responses and if they couldn't always explain exactly what they meant, they gave clear examples in actual fights. In his post above Kevin actually quotes a referee I interviewed, Wanchai Prowsee (who was voted best referee/judge at Rajadamnern in 2003) and trains judges at the stadium), he said when considering an equally effective punch and body kick exchange, the body kick would win because "it is the logo of Muay Thai and a punch is international".

The best evidence I can suggest is to watch lots Thai fights judged in Thailand. This particular fight between Daitan and Jamal is actually a great example of the emphasis on particular weapons in scoring, but given this fight is the 'bone of contention' I realise that is a circular argument. While not quite the same, there is another example of an aggressive puncher losing a world title fight in Thailand against kick and knee, this fight also illustrates the importance of particular techniques in determining the winner (this fight was judged by top Thai officials in Thailand).

http://muaythaijudging.com/fight-1.php

Create Topic

Username:
Password: Forget your password?
Topic name:
Create in:
 

Search Forum

Search topics for keywords: