Taken from secondsout.com

Should the Hit Man move down to 140lbs, or stay at 147 and fight bigger names? What are his chances of winning against some of the big names, and how exciting will the fights be?

Floyd Mayweather-147

Mayweather has the advantage here, as Hatton looks far too slow at Welterweight. Mayweather would be far too fast for Hatton, and would take a comfortable decision.

Excitement Factor: 6/10
Chance of winning: 30%

Floyd Mayweather 140

The odds should narrow considerably, as Hatton is a monster at this weight. He is fast and very strong at this weight, and should be able to give Mayweather the toughest fight of his career.

Excitement Factor: 7/10
Chance of winning: 45%

Miguel Cotto- 140

A great, great match up of styles. The patient stalker versus the relentless aggressor would make for a very entertaining, action packed fight. Hatton probably has the edge here due to his phenomenal pace and Cotto's shaky whiskers.

Excitement Factor: 9/10
Chance of winning: 60%


Jose Luis Castillo

Another mouth watering match-up. Castillo is an absolute monster at 135, and had fought at 140 several times before (and even all the way up to 150lbs). It would be a fight in a phone booth for the entire bout, with both fighters dissecting each other's midsections. Neither man would have the advantage up close, as Castillo's craftiness would make up for Hatton's volume. However, Hatton is still that little bit bigger, and he will find Castillo's chin more frequently than Diego Corrales.

Chance of winning: 55%
Excitement Factor: 10/10

Diego Corrales- 140

Another huge Lightweight who would retain his punch power at 140. However, if Hatton could walk through Tszyu's bombs, then he won't have a problem with Chico's. Corrales long torso would provide Hatton with a huge target, and the Hitman would hit it all night.

Chance of winning: 70%
Excitement Factor: 9/10

Luis Collazo, rematch at 147.

This would be a fight where whoever could make the adjustment wins. Hatton is an intelligent boxer, but he is not a reflexive fighter like Collazo. Collazo probably has more room to adjust, so would probably be the favourite to win the rematch with Hatton. At 147, Hatton loses most of his advantages against his opponents, as out muscling and out working them play a huge part of his strategy.

Chance of winning: 45%
Excitement Factor: 6/10

Arturo Gatti-147

This is an interesting and entertaining match up. Gatti is the bigger puncher at this weight, but Hatton is the better all round fighter. Hatton may get hit more by Gatti at 147 but he should retain enough strength and speed to beat the Canadian to the punch. This should take the older man out of his comfort zone, and give Hatton the edge.

Chance of winning: 65%
Excitement Factor: 9/10

Junior Witter-140

Witter keeps promising good performances, but has not really delivered for quite some time (his last semi decent fight was almost 2 years ago against Lovemore N'dou). The switch-hitting Bradford puncher is dangerous, but Hatton would be too strong and too relentless.

Chance of winning: 70%
Excitement Factor 7/10

Oscar DeLaHoya 147

If Oscar could make 147lbs, this fight would be a real thriller. However, given the Golden Boys recent destruction of Ricardo Mayorga, he would be far too big and far too powerful for an already undersized Hatton at the Welterweight limit.

Chance of winning: 25%
Excitement Factor: 9/10