Topic:Report Post to Moderators
Felix,
First of all I totally agree with you that the K-1 needs a rating system badly and applaud your attempts - it's obvious that a lot of work has gone into it. However, even with your explanation that you don't count the 2nd or 3rd fights of a night in the equation your ranking for Jason Suttie is still hard to understand - do you only count fights in official K-1 events or do you also count fights between K-1 fighters under other rules? If it's only k-1 events then I suppose it would be a little more understandable but if you count 'outside' fights then you would have to include Jason's victory over Auckland Auimatagi under full Thai rules for one of his 6 world titles, his draw with Peter Graham (who he later defeated in the KB4) and his victory over Hiriwa Te Rangi. Doug Viney would only have victories over Dion Crouch, Chris Chrisopoulides and Oliver Tuisefia count towards his ranking because almost all of his fights were in k-1 8 man tournaments. With Jason having defeated Mike Angove, Nathan Briggs(or was it Paul, cant remember) in the first stage of k-1 8 man tournaments (+ the other guy whose name has also slipped my mind that he just beat in the nz vs croatia k-1)I still cant figure out how come Doug (or Ron Sefo for that matter) rank higher than Jason (though I'm sure that it will change after the k-1 Oceania). Your system would seem to penalise NZ fighters because the K-1 NZ and K-1 Oceania are both 8 man tournaments.